The West That Wasnt - Initiative And Action Speeds
When the game enters action time, speed and order of operations become vitally important. The initiative system below describes how to use action speeds to determine action sequence.
Contents
Action Time vs Narrative Time
The West That Wasnt differentiates between action time and narrative time in the following manner. Narrative time is any time during the game when detailed timekeeping and movement is unnecessary. In narrative time, the passage of a few minutes, or even an hour or more, can be assumed to occur as dictated by the story. It is likewise unnecessary to know the detailed moment to moment location of characters and NPCs.
The most common usage for action time is combat, but it is also used for any encounter where time and relative placement of characters is crucial. In these situations, the order of operations has an immediate impact on the game world and the actions that follow.
Action Speeds
TWTW classifies actions in one of three speed categories: Quick, Half, and Full (some continuous actions such as Dodge or covering fire are special cases). Action speeds are used to determine the order of actions each round. Heroes may perform two Half actions and one Quick action per turn, or one Full action. Quick actions may be substituted for Half actions freely, but not vice versa. In other words, three Quick actions would be legal, three Half actions would not.
Heroes may choose to perform fewer actions than allotted, which increase the odds that their action will resolve earlier in the phase. See the declarations section, below, for more on this.
Example Action Speeds
The following list provides the speed of some common actions. The list is not exhaustive, but it does cover most situations. The Judge is the final authority regarding the speed of any action that is not listed here.
Quick Actions
Some martial arts attacks
Fast weapons such as pistols and knives
Cocking and readying of some weapons.
Reloading cartridge weapons.
Half Actions
Brawl
Weapons such as swords and carbines
Skill use
Ready item
Reload bow
Full Actions
Extended action. Extended actions are complex skill checks requiring multiple victories to complete, or any other task that may take longer than one round.
Loading muzzle loading weapons and complex breech loaders.
Some actions, such as movement, may be of different speeds depending on choices made by the player. For example, you can move further with a Full move than with a Quick one. The difference is when the action takes place (more on this later).
Special Cases
Use item - by item
Aimed shot - depends on weapon type (listed on gear page).
Example item speeds:
The previous image shows the traits for pistols. The SPD column is the action speed of the weapon (followed by the speed to cock/ready), while the Aim column lists the speed of an aim action as well as the snap shot penalty.
Combat Actions and Determining Speed
During combat, characters perform actions in response to a changing environment and situation. During a combat encounter, there are five broad categories of actions that may be performed by a Hero. The first is the tactical move, which is any action which includes both a move and a ranged attack. The second is an advance, which includes any move action combined with a hand to hand attack of any kind. The third is a maneuver, which includes any move action that does not also include attacks. The fourth is the attack action, which is any attack that does not also include movement. The final type of action is called a freestyle action, which encompasses everything else.
Free Actions
Some actions are so fast or simple that they are determined to be free. Each character may do one free action per round in addition to any other actions. Any further free actions count as a fast action and must be combined as described below. Some examples of free actions are talking (a sentence or two), giving a hand signal, or dropping an item.
Maneuver
During combat, there are four possible movement types: Step, Quick, Half and Full. Step is a special case of combining a Quick action with a movement (see Tactical Move, below, for more). Quick, Half and Full movements are the standard combat moves. Movement can be combined with other actions as described under Freestyle Actions.
Freestyle Actions
Any action which is not one of the other actions types is a freestyle action. This includes performing less than the full action allotment. The combining action rules, below, outline how to determine the overall action speed for actions that are less than allowed.
A Hero may perform up to two Half Actions and one Quick action in a turn. Quick actions may be substituted for Half actions, but not the opposite. Alternatively, a Hero may perform a Full action.
Freestyle Action Speeds
A character who is performing a single action has an action speed equal to the speed of that action. A character performing multiple actions must use the following rules to determine the combined action speed for declaration purposes. When combining two actions, the resulting speed is one slower than the slowest action in the group. Three Quick actions can be combined to be Full. No other three action combination is allowed.
1. A Full action may never be combined with any other action.
2. No more than three actions may be combined in a round (plus up to one free action, as above).
3. Three Quick actions may be combined as a Full action.
4. Two Half actions may be combined as a Full action.
5. One Quick and one Half action may be combined as a Half action.
6. Two Quick actions may be combined as a Half action.
In general, non-combat skill use may not be combined with combat actions.
Tactical Move
The Tactical Move combines a quick or half move with a fire or throw action. It may also include aim or cock actions, if desired. Tactical actions are half or full actions depending on the gear and movement. This is one of the most common actions during combat, and therefore has many structured examples and options presented. Tactical actions cannot be performed with gear that has the Slow attribute, but may be performed with Fast and Normal gear.
Most tactical moves are Full actions. Depending on the situation, a Hero may wish to cock, aim or move in Step or Quick distances. The following table denotes what is possible with a tactical move.
The only tactical moves that can be performed with a Half action are snap shots (without aim), with single or double action pistols. If the weapon needs to be cocked, the movement distance is reduced accordingly.
Advance Action
The advance action combines movement with a hand to hand attack. More to come.
Examples
Hank Daggett wishes to load a '58 Springfield musket, which is a Full action. This may not be combined with any other action. He declares a Full action.
More examples needed.
Simultaneous Actions
In rare cases a character may attempt actions that are simultaneous. This is distinct from when two actions can normally be performed together, such as moving and firing a weapon (that case is a combination of actions as described above). If a character wishes to do one handed actions with each hand at the same time, those actions are simultaneous for the purposes of this rule. Some examples are firing weapons, drawing or readying items or some combination (draw a knife and fire a pistol, for example).
Unfortunately the human mind is terrible at multitasking. The penalties and rules for attempting simultaneous actions and for off-handed actions are described in the conflict chapter. Determining the speed of those actions is discussed here.
When performing two simultaneous actions, count them as a single action for combination purposes, with a speed equal to the slowest of the actions being attempted.
Initiative
What follows is a description of how to sequence action rounds.
Overview
The sequence works as follows.
I. Declare.
A. Characters declare speed of intended action.
II. Resolve.
A. Flip card(s) and determine Reflex results for all characters.
B. Determine phase for each character.
III. Act
A. Starting in Phase I, characters act in Reflex order.
Phases and Round Timing
Each action round is divided into four phases (I-IV). All actions in the first phase occur before any actions in the second phase. Within each phase actions occur in descending order based on Reflex die (first type, then number). Further ties are broken in favor of the Crew, or Judge discretion, in that order.
After all four phases have resolved the round is over, and if necessary a new one is begun.
Phases and Simultaneity
Each action round is divided into four phases. During each phase, ties are broken by Reflex die type. The ties are meaningful in that actions are fully resolved before moving on to the next, but in terms of relative timing, everything in phase I is taking place at roughly the same time, just a moment or two before phase II.
In TWTW the rules do not differentiate between moving before or after an action. If another character goes during the same phase, that character can choose to take their action in the most advantageous way available. This means that even if you have Reflex d12, if you move from cover to cover, but expose yourself at some point during the phase, even a goon acting on d4 during that phase can fire during the exposed movement.
Wait a minute, this means that fast characters, such as those with d12 Reflex, are exposed more often than slower ones! Those with a d4 Reflex are never exposed!
For the purpose of this rule, during the same phase means since the last instance of your Reflex die, starting with the beginning of the round. This means that the d12 Reflex character who goes in Phase I (or any other phase, just for reference), will be exposed until the beginning of the next Phase.
Miranda has an empty Peacemaker in one hand, and her eyes on her other Peacemaker, across the street in her horse saddle. She knows that two bloodthirsty vaqueros are watching her from hidden vantage points. When her action comes up, on d10 in Phase I, she decides to run to her horse and grab the loaded pistol. After her action resolves, she will remain a valid target in the open until the end of the d10 Reflex portion of Phase II.
To keep the suspense, it is suggested that after everyone determines which phase they will act, they should place their initiative token on the respective spot on their character sheet (without saying the phase aloud) and cover it with their hand or some other item. The card used to resolve the initiative can be kept aside, in case something needs to be rechecked for some reason. This way, you never know who will pop out and take a shot!
But What About When...
The rules laid out previously are fairly simple, and cover the vast majority of situations. There are, however, times when those rules do not fully cover the situation at hand. Rather than attempt to write a set of rules that effectively covers every situation, a few guidelines are presented to allow you to play the game you want to play. In TWTW, many options and decisions are provided, but that could never take the place of good storytelling and judgment, so why even try?
To some, this may seem counter to the mission of TWTW. Recall that the design goals included delivering maximum detail without sacrificing speed. The West That Wasnt has many options, which leads to many choices, but the choices themselves are relatively simple. Attempting to provide exhaustive rules that cover all possibilities would not only increase complexity markedly, in exchange for the ability to handle a small subset of situations, but it would also unduly hamper speed. All of this with almost no perceivable gain.
The West That Wasnt delivers meaningful choices, not complex minutiae.
Back to the situation. Simultaneous actions can lead to confusion in situations involving range, when the TN might vary, and when physical contact is necessary to the action. The rules provide three general guidelines, but the actual implementation is relegated to the Judge at the table.
Guideline 1: The character taking the current action does so at the most advantageous time for the action. This means that if there is a place during the movement where a shot can be taken and have a lower difficulty, the character will take the advantage. If there is a choice (such as between lower difficulty with increased cover versus higher difficulty), the player controlling the acting character can make the choice. In case of NPCs, the Judge decides.
Guideline 2: If there is a question regarding physical contact between characters, previous actions are fully resolved before the next one is attempted. This means that unless a character is using a delayed action (which would allow interruption), they would not be able to tackle another character running by. The tackle would need to take place where the previously moving character stopped moving.
Guideline 3: If after applying previous rules a question persists, the Judge decides. Players should accept the ruling of the Judge. If, however, it is unclear how one rule or another applies, or how a situation should be interpreted, cut the deck and check the toggle result (lower right). Yes favors the player, No favors the Judge. Once the deck is cut, the ruling stands (do not continue to discuss, or adjust the situation based on other rules or new information). This should be used sparingly, but is preferable to extended discussions regarding the proper rule interpretation. Keep the game moving!
Determining Initiative
The initiative system involves two steps: declaration and resolution. During the declaration phase, players take turns indicating the speed their character will be acting during this round. After all characters have declared, a card is drawn to resolve the initiative order.
Declaration
At the beginning of the round, all characters that are participating in the action declare their intentions. Each character declares in turn. Normally, the order of declarations is unimportant, however, if the Crew wishes declarations can be ordered in ascending Reflex order. Players should not be allowed to change their action speed declaration in response to another declaration (though normally it should not matter, as previously stated), but this can be allowed with Judge discretion.
It is recommended that each player have a counter for each speed: Fast, Normal and Slow. This way, everyone can select their speed token and reveal simultaneously.
When making a declaration, the player indicates the speed of the action they wish to perform this round. No more specificity is required. The goal of the declaration is to define how quickly a character is acting during the round, not to force a decision before the situation has an opportunity to unfold. When their turn arrives, they may choose any action that has the declared speed or higher.
Examples
Hank wishes to fire at one of the Laroq posse that is surrounding him. His double action Thunderer has an action speed of Quick. He declares a Half action so he may also move. He does not need to declare a target. When it is his turn to act, he can choose any target he wishes. He may also choose to do any action that has a higher action speed, such as running away (Quick or Half action) or yelling to his compatriots (free action).
Jonah is moving along a corridor and has declared a Half action. Before he acts, Angus Laroq appears in the doorway in front of him. On his action, he may continue moving (maneuver, Half action) or fire with his Peacemaker (Quick). He may even do both (Tactical Move, Half action or Full depending on how far he moves). But he may not tie a lariat with his rope (Freestyle, Full) in anticipation of entangling Mr. Laroq.
Miranda is out in the open at Angus Laroq's hacienda while two men with rifles are drawing a bead on her. The distance is too far for her Peacemakers, so she declares she is dodging and moving in order to close the distance and try to keep from getting plugged. Miranda gains the "Dodging" attribute immediately, but her movement will resolve as a Half action.
Resolution
Once all characters have declared their speed for the round, flip a card and determine the initiative sequence. Each action card has an initiative bar on the bottom edge.
The initiative bar is structured like a table, with the action speed on the left, the TN to the right arranged in columns headed by the appropriate action phase (I-IV). There is a separate table for each action speed (fast, normal and slow). The table tells the TN required to act in that phase with an action of that speed.
To determine when the action occurs, use the cause grid to check Reflexes (see The West That Wasnt_-_Action_Cards#Performing_Skill_and_Attribute_Checks for instructions). Compare the result to the given TN. The character can choose to act in any phase where their Reflex check meets or exceeds the TN (but only one of them, that choice is made now). In the given table, a fast action would resolve in phase I on a 7+, phase II on a 5+, phase III on a 3+ and phase IV on a 1+. If it were instead a slow action the TNs would be 13, 11, 8, 3 respectively. Once a character knows which phase they will act, place the initiative declaration counter on the given phase on their combat reference aid, located on the reverse of the character sheet (or otherwise note the phase).
If a character does not generate a TN high enough to go in phase 4, the character hesitates and does not go this round. Next round his action is considered one speed category faster, with a maximum speed of fast. If the Reflex result is CF, the character does not act this round, and gets no bonus to speed next round. They also are considered to hesitate.
Optional Resolution System
The system uses a single card flip for all participants. It is relatively simple and fast this way. However, it is entirely feasible that your group could choose to use one card per side, or even one card per character (or henchman group). The system works exactly the same in either instance.
Taking Actions
Once all characters have determined in which phase they will act, the round begins in phase 1. The Judge calls out the phase, beginning with 1, and all characters who will go in that phase indicate such. If there are multiple characters going in a phase, ties are broken based on Reflex, in favor of larger dice, then number of dice. Ties that persist are broken in favor of the players. Ties between NPCs are broken by the Judge. If no characters act in a phase it can be skipped.
When a character has an action, they may perform any action they choose as long as the action speed of the given action is equal to or faster than the speed they declared. This allows characters to react to a changing scene, while still needing to use planning and strategy during the declaration phase.
Repeat the process for phases 2-4. Once they are complete, the round ends. If another round is necessary, start again from the declarations.
Delaying an Action
Sometimes a character will be ready to perform an action, but the situation is not yet appropriate for one reason or another. In this case, that character may delay their action. If the phase/Reflex when a character is slated to act arrives, and they wish to delay instead, there are two choices: they may declare they are waiting for a specific set of circumstances, or they may declare they wish to wait until a later time to act.
If they declare a set of circumstances the round continues to the next character. As soon as the given circumstance occurs, they may immediately take their action as if they had an action this phase, on the next Reflex level. In other words, it is always "in phase" with the action that just occurred.
If the circumstance has still not occurred by the end of the round the character may state they are continuing to wait for the circumstance. This counts as a fast action for determining readiness in the new round, but as the speed of the initial action for all other purposes. If at any time the character wishes to stop waiting for the circumstance they may announce their intent before any action. In this case, they may perform their action immediately after the current action, following all appropriate rules to do so.
If a character wishes to delay until later without declaring a circumstance, they may announce their intent to perform an action at any time after another action completes. If they wish to attempt to preempt another action, a Reflex contest must be resolved with the interrupting character suffering a -2 penalty. If they win, they may go first. Otherwise, they go after the triggering action completes. Note that preempting another action is rarely necessary, given the rules on simultaneity, above. If two characters wished to reach into a trough and grab a dropped Bowie knife, then order of action matters. If one character wishes to shoot another after they leave a doorway, but before they round a corner, they may do so.
Miranda is certain that the hombre that kidnapped Jonah is going to be coming around the corner at the end of the hall any moment now, so she declares a fast action. Her Reflex check produces an 8, so she goes in Phase I. No one has appeared by the time her action comes, so she declares to the Judge that she will fire at the cowboy as soon as he is visible. During Phase III a cowboy attempts to dart across the hall into an open door. Since Miranda had declared she was waiting for this, she fires on him before he enters the open door.
Jonah is being pursued by Angus and one of his flunkies after he has escaped the cell in his hacienda. His only chance to escape is to make it to the livery and hope that Miranda is waiting for him there, with their horses. To be continued
Initiative Example, Jonah Benton Runs From the Perkins Brothers
Jonah is attempting to escape from the Perkins brothers, armed with Bowie knives, after he won a bit too much cash for their liking at an evening poker game. The brothers declare they will attempt a fast action. Jonah also declares a fast action.
The initiative card is drawn.
Jonah gets 6.
According to the initiative table, fast actions require a 7 to go in phase I, a 5 to go in II or later. He chooses to go in phase II (his generated result, 6, is at least 5, for phase II, but less than 7, for phase I). He could have chosen II, III or IV.
Luckily for him, the brothers get CF. Even though the 1-6 result is an exceptional result, because the 2-6 cell is CF they must choose CF. See The_West_That_Wasnt_-_Action_Cards#Critical_Failures for more on critical failures and exceptional results.
When the Judge calls out phase II, Jonah indicates he will run around the corner (a fast action). Because the brothers got a CF result, they hesitate and do nothing this round. Clearly the brothers do not have what it takes to handle Jonah, at the card table or outside the saloon.
Initiative Example 2, Miranda and Reuben Square Off Against the Laroq posse
While making their escape from the hacienda cell where Angus had incarcerated them, Miranda and Hank were spotted by a sentry, and a handful of vaqueros close in on their location.
Miranda and Hank know they have been spotted, and they surmise hombres are approaching, but they are unsure of how many, and from which direction they will come. In fact, they know precious little about the danger ahead. From their position behind cover, the two weigh options for a moment before the Judge asks for declarations.
The Reflex scores of the participants are as follows:
Hank: 2d6
Miranda: 3d10
Hombre 1: 2d10
Hombre 2: 2d10
Hombre 3: 2d10
The declarations are as follows:
Hank is armed with a double barreled shotgun he picked up from inside the ranch house, speed normal. He intends to hold the line here, and give Miranda a chance to run for it. His declaration is normal speed action.
Hombre 1 declares a normal speed action. Unbeknownst to the heroes, he is armed with a lasso. He intends to prevent Hank from firing on his comrades (and himself).
Hombre 2 declares a fast action. This cowboy is armed with a heavy club, he intends to close the distance on Miranda, so that next round he can easily wallop her upside the head (very ungentlemanly, this hombre). Running is a fast action.
Hombre 3 declares a normal action. He is the backup plan, in case either or both of his partners fail. He is armed with a .44 Army single action revolver, cocked. The pistol is a fast action, but he wishes to see how their plan progresses before acting. He may choose to move, or fire, but since Angus wants these two alive if possible, firing is a last resort. Since he declared a normal action, he may freely use a fast action as well.
Miranda declares a fast action, but she has no intention of leaving Reuben here on his own. She plans on using her Peacemakers to clear the field so that she and Hank can make their escape together.
A card is drawn (28):
Hank has 2d6 Reflexes, so he gets a 2.
Since he declared a normal speed action, he goes in phase IV.
The Hombres have 2d10 Reflexes, so they get 7.
Hombres 1 and 3 declared normal speed actions, so they also go in phase III, because 7 is greater than or equal to 5 but less than 8.
Hombre 2 declared a fast action, so he goes in phase I.
Miranda declared a fast action, and generates an 8 on 3d10.
She goes in phase 1 because 8 is greater than or equal to 7.
The action will unfold like this. Miranda will be ready to fire immediately, but no targets will be present (her 3d10 Reflexes goes before the 2d10 for hombre 2) so she will delay until a target exists. Hombre 2 will sprint toward her, revealing himself. A Reflex test will commence to determine if the hombre closes the distance before Miranda fires. Hombres 1 and 3 will go in phase III. Hombre 1 will attempt to entangle Reuben with his lariat. Hombre 3 will choose a target or move based on how the previous actions unfold. Finally, in phase IV, Hank will either fire on visible hombres or attempt to free himself from the lasso (also a normal speed action).
Note that had Reuben declared a fast action he would not be able to attempt to free himself this round (assuming he was successfully entangled). His haste would have cost him an opportunity to react effectively.
The Goal of Action Speeds: Tactical Verisimilitude
Oftentimes we as gamers confuse realism for the illusion of realism, or, verisimilitude. The goal of The West That Wasnt combat system, and the action speeds in particular, is not to simulate reality exactly, or even closely. Instead, the goal is to emulate the choices made by individuals, and give the illusion of a realistic world unfolding in our collective imagination.
Single action revolvers were more common in the west even after double action became widely produced. The Colt Single Action Army (Peacemaker) was time tested and trusted by many successful gunfighters. In the real world, the single action is simpler, and just slightly faster (once cocked, that is). The double action is easier and more flexible (cocking is optional), but the heavier trigger pull makes accuracy unreliable after more than a few paces. In TWTW, we aim to make those small differences into choices your Heroes and villains can make for themselves. The goal of the system is to give similar choices to the players, and let those choices provide an experience that simulates the feel of combat without trying to reproduce it exactly. Winning initiative based ties with other firearms might not come up every round, but it sure is nice when you need it.
The same thing is true with aim. The TWTW aim system requires a small shift in perspective. Many gamers will forgo the bonus aiming grants rather than spend actions increasing the chance to hit. In TWTW, aiming most weapons does not grant a bonus. Rather, it removes a penalty. Gamers abhor penalties.
What the system does is grant a very real speed advantage to a skilled shooter, while still making even a beginner extremely deadly if given an opportunity. With open ended damage rolls, every weapon in the game can kill you.
A regular Joe with a Peacemaker and one level in pistol has a 33% chance to hit with an aimed shot at 10 paces. The most likely area of hits is the torso, either chest or belly. An average hit does 1 wound and 5 Concussion, with around 40% of hits dealing 2+ wounds. Only about 5% of hits fail to cause a wound. With only 5 wound points available in the torso, even only a 33% chance is extremely dangerous. That is a Half action, generally going in phase II or III. Add one more level in pistol, and this regular guy is a serious threat to the life of anyone on the other end of their shooting iron.
What sets the great shooters apart is not their ability to hit with aimed shots, instead it is their ability to fire quickly, without aiming, and still hit consistently, while also often bumping damage and hit location to make their shots even deadlier. A skilled gunfighter with 3d10 in pistol, and that same Peacemaker, can hit that Joe a little more than 2/3 of the time with a Quick action, going in phase I or II reliably. After that first hit, even if Joe survives, his once very deadly 33% accuracy plummets to under 5%: a veritable crap shoot.
Taking penalties is counter to the way many gamers think, yet a -2 is not the same to an expert as it is to a novice.
Choosing the right tool is also paramount. Rifles are bigger and deal larger wounds. They are also slower to aim and only accurate when you do. At close ranges, a pistol is much more reliable. Get more than 20 paces or so, however, and the rifle becomes a very attractive option.
Another point to consider is the use of cover and covering fire. Aiming is great when there is no threat, but aiming under fire is extremely difficult. A shot need not hit to destroy the aim of the target. This makes even unskilled fighters useful in combat, if for nothing else than keeping the heads of enemies down.
Parking yourself behind cover is the most effective way to counteract covering fire. The stronger the cover, the greater the bonus to the Bravery check to resist losing aim.
All of these points lead to one conclusion: there is no "one true way" to succeed at combat. Every situation is different, and characters of all skill levels can be quite effective. The variety of choices is what makes TWTW what it is. The game was designed for mechanical depth, so that instead of picking up the same dice and rolling the same thing over and over, every round is a unique challenge.
Characters that work together to utilize the tools at their disposal, the scene of the encounter, and the varied skills they possess will be significantly more effective.
